Colfax prosecution: the verdicts that reached the Supreme Court
The Colfax prosecution produced a striking gap between the number of people indicted and the number found guilty. The Federal Judicial Center records 97 people indicted in connection with the 1873 massacre in Louisiana, but only three convictions. Those verdicts concerned a federal conspiracy to interfere with constitutional rights under the Enforcement Act of 1870. Subsequent judicial proceedings prevented judgments of conviction from standing, and the Supreme Court directed that the defendants be discharged in 1876.
The violence followed Louisiana's disputed election of 1872. According to the National Archives' account accompanying the surviving federal case file, Black freedmen and state militia occupied the Grant Parish courthouse at Colfax. A white force, including former Confederate soldiers, overpowered them. The Archives identifies three white deaths and an uncertain, much larger number of Black deaths. The confrontation belonged to the struggle over political authority after emancipation, with the courthouse and parish government at its center.
The constitutional changes preceding the Colfax prosecution had arrived in stages. The Thirteenth Amendment, ratified in 1865, abolished slavery with its stated exception for punishment after criminal conviction. The Fourteenth, ratified in 1868, defined national and state citizenship and prohibited states from denying due process or equal protection. The Fifteenth, ratified in 1870, prohibited racial discrimination in voting by the United States or any state. Each included a congressional enforcement power. Their different wording became central to the judicial arguments about federal authority.
Congress enacted the voting-rights legislation of May 31, 1870, against that constitutional background. Its opening section addressed otherwise qualified citizens at elections across the country's territorial and local subdivisions, without distinctions of race, color, or previous servitude. Other sections concerned election administration and interference with voting. Section 6 reached conspiracies intended to hinder the enjoyment of rights granted or secured by the Constitution or federal law. It classified the offense as a felony and prescribed possible fines, imprisonment, and disqualification from federal offices of honor, profit, or trust.
The Supreme Court's published account described an indictment containing 32 counts. Three defendants were found guilty on the first 16 and acquitted on the others. The surviving counts named Levi Nelson and Alexander Tillman and referred to assembly, arms, personal liberty, equal treatment, and voting. The indictment used parallel sets of allegations, one describing people banding together and another describing conspiracy. The many counts therefore did not represent an equal number of convictions or separate defendants.
Judicial disagreement emerged after the verdicts. Justice Joseph P. Bradley and circuit judge William Woods sat together in the federal circuit court. Bradley favored arresting judgment because he considered the indictment legally insufficient; Woods disagreed. The divided court certified the dispute for Supreme Court consideration. The controversy concerned the legal foundation of the Colfax prosecution, including whether the particular rights alleged fell within the federal statute and whether the charges described the necessary elements with sufficient precision.
Bradley's position, as explained by the Federal Judicial Center, distinguished constitutional guarantees from restrictions addressed to state governments. He treated the Thirteenth Amendment's abolition of slavery as a positive constitutional command. He also recognized congressional authority concerning racial discrimination in voting under the Fifteenth Amendment. Nevertheless, he found the voting allegations deficient because they did not expressly allege the racial purpose he considered essential. He rejected other counts because of their constitutional foundation or their generality. His objections reached both the scope of national power and the language of the accusations.
Chief Justice Waite delivered the Supreme Court's opinion. It concluded that the challenged counts were legally insufficient and affirmed the order arresting judgment, with instructions to discharge the defendants. The ruling addressed the charges and the constitutional authority supporting them. The case had already passed through indictment and guilty verdicts; the later order prevented those verdicts from becoming an effective federal punishment. In its historical assessment, the Federal Judicial Center describes the result as a major setback for federal efforts to prosecute racial violence during Reconstruction.
The act also assigned enforcement to federal institutions. Section 8 gave U.S. district courts jurisdiction over offenses under the law, with concurrent circuit-court jurisdiction over civil and criminal causes. It placed those federal offenses outside the jurisdiction of state courts. Section 9 authorized and required district attorneys, marshals, and other designated officials to institute proceedings at federal expense. Congress had created both substantive offenses and an institutional structure for enforcement. That structure supplied the forum for a prosecution whose constitutional foundation became contested at Colfax.
The National Archives preserves a separate material trace of the Colfax prosecution: Criminal Case No. 12, United States v. Columbus Nash and others, dated 1873. It belongs to Record Group 21 and the Fort Worth collection of federal court case files. The archival case title and the Supreme Court's title, United States v. Cruikshank, identify different parts of the proceedings that followed the violence at the parish courthouse.
- Federal Judicial Center, Associate Justice Joseph P. Bradley: United States v. Cruikshank (1874) — www.fjc.gov
- U.S. Supreme Court, United States v. Cruikshank, 92 U.S. 542 (1876) — www.law.cornell.edu
- National Archives, Colfax Riot: U.S. v. Columbus Nash and others, Criminal Case No. 12 — www.archives.gov
- U.S. Congress, Enforcement Act of May 31, 1870, 16 Stat. 140–146 — www.govinfo.gov
- National Archives, The Constitution: Amendments 11–27, including Amendments XIII–XV — www.archives.gov