A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

The soldiers’ trial and its divided outcome

Boston Massacre trial: separate defendants and different verdicts

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Debunk

Boston Massacre trial: separate defendants and different verdicts

The Boston Massacre trial of eight soldiers ended with two manslaughter convictions and six acquittals. Hugh Montgomery and Matthew Kilroy were the two men convicted. Captain Thomas Preston had already faced a separate proceeding and been acquitted. These were distinct judgments arising from the shootings on King Street on March 5, 1770; three civilians died that night, and two others died later from their wounds. The authorities denied the soldiers' request to be tried together with their captain.

The March 13 indictment concerning Crispus Attucks placed the case within the king's colonial courts. Its formal heading named the Superior Court of Judicature, Court of Assizes, and General Gaol Delivery, sitting in Suffolk County. The document accused William Warren of firing the shots that killed Attucks. It named Preston, the other soldiers, and four civilian customs employees as aiding and abetting the alleged murder. Similar indictments concerned the other four victims. The grand jury's language alleged an intentional killing committed with malice; it set out the Crown's accusation before the evidence was contested at trial.

Royal officials postponed the proceedings amid concerns about local feeling. As the National Park Service explains, loyalists feared vengeance from colonists, while colonists feared that sympathetic officials would arrange dismissals. James Forrest approached John Adams on Preston's behalf after other lawyers had declined the case. Adams joined the defense despite the potential cost to his reputation. Preston's trial began on October 24 and ended in an acquittal on October 30. The Boston Massacre trial of the soldiers began on November 27, with Adams and Josiah Quincy continuing for the defense and Sampson Salter Blowers joining them.

Preston's proceeding turned on whether he had ordered the men to fire. The surviving evidence includes sharply conflicting witness accounts. Daniel Calef identified Preston as the officer who gave that command. Richard Palmes, who placed himself close to the captain, recalled hearing the word after the first shot but could not identify the speaker. Palmes accepted that Preston might have spoken without his being certain of it. Matthew Murray said he was within two yards of Preston, looking at him, and heard no order. Those statements differed on the central conduct attributed to the officer, rather than merely on incidental details.

Other witnesses supplied still different descriptions. Daniel Cornwall placed Preston in front of the soldiers and recalled a voice objecting to the firing, which he believed was the captain's. Jane Whitehouse attributed encouragement to a man in dark clothing whom she expressly distinguished from Preston. Her account also placed the captain to one side. The surviving statements consequently recorded both accusations against Preston and accounts favorable to him. They did not yield one unanimous description of who spoke, where he stood, or what the words meant. The captain's eventual acquittal preceded the adjudication of the individual soldiers' responsibility.

In the Boston Massacre trial of the soldiers, Adams challenged identification evidence as well as the interpretation of the confrontation. His surviving summation discussed a witness named Bass, who had identified Warren as the first man to fire. Adams disputed that identification. He also discussed Bridgham, whose sighting of another similar-looking soldier had made him uncertain about Warren. Adams noted that witnesses generally had not known the soldiers' names or faces beforehand. These were specific objections made by defense counsel to the evidence presented in this prosecution, with the jury left to assess the witnesses.

Adams also used testimony offered by the Crown in support of his defense. In his summation, he emphasized Bridgham's account of objects being thrown and contact with the soldiers' weapons. He argued that evidence describing the crowd's conduct affected the classification of the killings. His legal argument distinguished a claim of self-defense from a finding of manslaughter following provocation. He particularly applied the latter argument to Montgomery. Adams's speech combined analysis of individual identifications with an account of the surrounding disturbance; it was advocacy for the accused, delivered before the jury's decision.

Linder's historical account describes the instructions delivered by Justices Trowbridge and Peter Oliver. Trowbridge emphasized malice as the distinction between murder and other homicides. After deliberating for less than three hours, the jury acquitted six soldiers and convicted Montgomery and Kilroy of manslaughter. The subsequent sentencing proceedings took place on December 14, when the two convicted men received reduced punishment through the benefit of clergy. Reactions remained divided. Linder records Samuel Adams's criticism of the soldiers' actions and John Adams's later satisfaction with the verdicts. The judgments settled the charges against the defendants while the broader political dispute over the troops continued.

The Question

How many of the eight soldiers tried together after the Boston Massacre were convicted of manslaughter?

Show the answer

The Answer

Two: Hugh Montgomery and Matthew Kilroy. The jury acquitted the other six soldiers, after Captain Thomas Preston had been acquitted in a separate trial.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.