Ed Gein: two killings, grave exhumations and a separate murder trial
Two killings were confirmed in Ed Gein's case: Mary Hogan's in 1954 and Bernice Worden's in 1957. The larger quantity of human remains recovered from his Wisconsin property did not establish a corresponding number of murders. Contemporary reporting followed investigators as they confronted that distinction, moving from the discoveries at the farm to admissions, criminal charges and examinations of graves. The victims' names and the origins of the other remains mattered more than a frightening inventory by itself.
Worden operated a hardware store in Plainfield. Her body was discovered at Gein's property on November 16, 1957. HISTORY's later reconstruction describes her son's suspicions and the search that followed. Investigators encountered remains and objects made from human tissue, alongside the evidence of her killing. The discoveries created a second investigative problem beyond finding the missing shopkeeper: determining whose remains were present and whether each person had been killed by the man possessing them.
The United Press dispatch printed in the Cleburne Times-Review on November 22 reported a specific legal step. The previous day, Gein had appeared before County Judge Boyd Clark on a charge concerning Worden's murder. Attorney William Belter entered a plea of innocent by reason of insanity and waived preliminary examination. The same dispatch reported admissions to killing two women and robbing nine graves. A murder charge, an admission about another victim and a statement about taking bodies from cemeteries were distinct pieces of the investigation.
That dispatch identified Hogan as a tavern operator from Pine Grove who had disappeared three years earlier. Later historical summaries place her death in 1954. Gein's statements linked her to the farm discoveries, but the November court appearance described by United Press concerned Worden. The distinction prevents two separate errors: counting every set of remains as another killing, or treating the two acknowledged killings as two murder verdicts delivered at the same proceeding. The initial legal process did not resolve all the investigative findings at once.
The November 22 report also described the psychiatric decisions still ahead. Circuit Judge Herbert Bunde could order examination by court-appointed psychiatrists or send Gein for observation at the state hospital in Waupun. Prosecutor Earl Kileen indicated that he would not oppose the insanity plea. These were contemporary statements about possible next steps, rather than a final determination of criminal responsibility. HISTORY places Ed Gein's commitment to the Waupun hospital in 1958, followed by a later transfer to Mendota. That sequence of hospital placements preceded and outlasted the eventual murder trial, rather than constituting a prison sentence for two convictions.
By November 26, physical examination of burial sites had changed the investigative picture. Another United Press dispatch in the Times-Review reported that county officials had opened two graves the previous day. One was empty; the other contained only scattered bones. Kileen said the findings supported Gein's statements that remains other than those of the two murdered women had been obtained from graves. This was tangible evidence of body removal, addressing why multiple people's remains could be present without establishing multiple additional homicides.
There was no single, uniform official decision to stop looking. The November 26 dispatch reported that local authorities were ending their investigation after the grave openings, while Governor Vernon Thomson directed state investigators to continue examining the circumstances. It also described further grave examinations as dependent on relatives' wishes. The difference between the local prosecutor's position and the governor's instruction matters: a newspaper announcement that one part of an investigation was closing did not mean every authority considered every issue settled.
Later examinations provide a more detailed picture of the grave evidence. The historical summary in Wikipedia describes an empty casket, another containing bones and a crowbar, and another with most of its body missing. It also distinguishes the initial finding that Ed Gein could not stand trial from the determination in 1968 that he could consult with counsel and participate in his defense. Fitness to face proceedings concerned his condition at that later time; it was separate from his mental condition when Worden was killed.
Judge Robert Gollmar heard the Worden case without a jury in 1968. A finding that Gein committed the murder was followed by a separate determination of insanity and continued institutional confinement. Hogan's killing did not become a second conviction in that trial. Ed Gein remained in psychiatric institutions until his death in 1984. The durable numerical distinction rests on identifiable victims and evidence of what happened to them: two killings, alongside the removal of other bodies from burial places. The grave findings explain the difference without making the recovery of human remains stand in for evidence of an additional murder.
- United Press, Butcher Slayer To Be Confined, Cleburne Times-Review, November 22, 1957, page 1 — contemporary court reporting, University of North Texas — texashistory.unt.edu
- United Press, Officials Drop Investigation In Butcher Deaths, Cleburne Times-Review, November 26, 1957, page 4 — contemporary exhumation reporting, University of North Texas — texashistory.unt.edu
- HISTORY, Body of Ed Gein's final victim, Bernice Worden, is found — retrospective chronology — www.history.com
- Wikipedia, Ed Gein — supplementary grave-examination and 1968 trial chronology — en.wikipedia.org