Matias Reyes: the confession, the DNA match and the 2002 reversal
Matias Reyes admitted in 2002 that he alone had raped and assaulted the woman known as the Central Park jogger. DNA from the attack matched him. That combination prompted a renewed investigation and the reversal of convictions against Antron McCray, Kevin Richardson, Raymond Santana, Yusef Salaam and Korey Wise. The critical change was more than another person accepting responsibility: investigators could compare his statements with physical evidence preserved from the assault on April 19, 1989.
Before Matias Reyes came forward, the prosecution had relied heavily on the teenagers' statements. The Innocence Project's case history describes prolonged interrogations and confessions that differed over the time, location and participants in the attack. Richardson, McCray, Santana and Wise gave videotaped statements; Salaam did not give a videotaped confession. The victim, Trisha Meili, recovered without a memory of the assault. Her injuries established the violence inflicted on her, but she could not supply a remembered identification of the person responsible. The original prosecutions went forward in two separate trials in 1990. Salaam's case history records a sentence of 5 to 10 years and nearly seven years served.
Physical evidence also required closer examination. At trial, hairs recovered from Richardson's clothing had been described as consistent with the victim's hair. Most decisively, the DNA profile from sperm in the rape kit matched Matias Reyes. The laboratory comparisons concerned different specimens and answered different questions. A resemblance under a microscope and a DNA identification were not equivalent findings.
District Attorney Robert Morgenthau's reinvestigation led to a recommendation that the convictions be set aside. Wikipedia's supplementary chronology describes the team led by prosecutors Nancy Ryan and Peter Casolaro and Ryan's December 2002 affirmation supporting the defendants' motions. The scope extended beyond the rape counts. Ryan concluded that statements about other crimes in the park could not reliably be separated from the statements about Meili's assault. The recommendation therefore addressed all the convictions, rather than merely removing one allegation from otherwise intact judgments.
Justice Charles J. Tejada vacated the five men's convictions on December 19, 2002. The legal change did not coincide with five simultaneous departures from prison: all had completed their sentences by then. It cleared the convictions and enabled removal from the sex-offender registry. This sequence separates the new evidence, the prosecutor's recommendation and the judge's order. A confession did not cancel a verdict by itself; the investigation prompted a formal application, followed by judicial action affecting the existing judgments.
An official record from the following decade shows how long compensation remained a separate struggle. At the City Council's March 25, 2010 stated meeting, Council Member Charles Barron and colleagues introduced Resolution 81 calling for compensation. Its text named the five men and connected the reversal to the DNA match and Reyes's admission that he acted alone. It also included Steven Lopez, who had entered a separate robbery plea. The resolution's broader group therefore should not be confused with the five defendants whose convictions were vacated together in 2002.
The resolution argued that imprisonment had taken years of the men's adolescence and that money could not fully restore those losses. Its operative request called on the city to compensate them. The minutes then recorded referral to the Committee on Governmental Operations. That procedural ending matters: this was a legislative demand for redress, rather than a court awarding damages or a completed settlement. By 2010, the criminal judgments had been removed for years, while the city's financial response remained contested in public proceedings.
PBS NewsHour's June 20, 2014 broadcast description reported a proposed $40 million resolution of the men's civil-rights lawsuit. It explicitly distinguished the convictions vacated in 2002 from the civil litigation lasting into 2014. The interval explains why the criminal reversal and the payment appear under different dates. They were different legal events, with the lawsuit addressing consequences of the prosecution after the convictions themselves had already been set aside.
On September 5, 2014, the city's Law Department announced a federal judge's approval of a $41 million settlement. Corporation Counsel Zachary Carter stated that DNA linked the individual claiming sole responsibility to the rape, while no DNA or other scientific evidence implicated the five men. He also maintained that settling did not acknowledge misconduct by detectives or prosecutors; that disputed liability would otherwise have gone to a jury. Mayor Bill de Blasio described compensation as a response to an overdue injustice. The same official statement thus recognized the evidentiary reversal while reserving the city's position on civil liability.
Matias Reyes's admission changed the case because it could be tested against the biological evidence. The resulting reversal removed criminal judgments; the later settlement resolved a civil dispute. Neither event needs to be folded into the other to understand what the DNA match accomplished.
- New York City Law Department, Statements on Central Park Five Settlement, September 5, 2014 — original official statement on DNA, vacatur and settlement terms — www.nyc.gov
- Innocence Project, Yusef Salaam — supplementary case history and forensic testing results — innocenceproject.org
- Wikipedia, Central Park jogger case — supplementary chronology of the Ryan recommendation and Tejada order — en.wikipedia.org
- New York City Council, March 25, 2010 stated-meeting minutes, Resolution 81, printed page CC46 — original compensation proposal and committee referral — www.nyc.gov
- PBS NewsHour, Struggle by Central Park 5 ends in $40 million settlement, June 20, 2014 — contemporary broadcast description — www.pbs.org