The Holmes confession and the people who were still alive
The Holmes confession named people who had not been murdered. H. H. Holmes claimed 27 killings, but several supposed victims were still alive, according to historian Adam Selzer's account of the case. The number itself therefore cannot serve as a verified total. Selzer identifies about nine people whom Holmes probably killed with some confidence. Evidence is strongest for his associate Benjamin Pitezel and three of Pitezel's children. Investigators tried and convicted Holmes for Benjamin's murder alone, giving that death a different evidentiary standing from the larger collection of claims attached to his name.
Other disappearances remain less certain. Julia Connor and her daughter Pearl vanished around Christmas 1891, after Julia had become involved with Holmes personally and through his business activities. Holmes alternately denied responsibility for Julia's death and confessed to killing her accidentally during an abortion he performed. Emeline Cigrand and sisters Minnie and Nannie Williams also disappeared after connections with him. The precise circumstances of their deaths remain unresolved. These cases contain missing people, suspicious relationships, and inconsistent statements; they do not provide independent confirmation of every killing Holmes chose to claim.
Contemporaries were already challenging the Holmes confession before his execution. On April 15, 1896, The Galveston Daily News carried a dispatch from Pittsburgh dated the previous day. It attributed its information to insurance inspector Gary of the Fidelity company, which had insured Pitezel. Gary said Holmes had not committed all the murders to which he had confessed. The dispatch placed Kate Durkee in Omaha, Dr. Russell in Michigan, Roma Van Fassant in Arkansas, and Robert Latimer in Chicago. These were named people located in specific places, contradicting the picture of an entirely dead list.
A further complication for the Holmes confession involved Gertrude Connor. The same Pittsburgh dispatch said that she had lived for six weeks after leaving Chicago for Iowa.
The investigation behind the Holmes confession began before his sweeping public claims. The Library of Congress chronology records Holmes' arrest in Boston in November 1894 on an accusation of attempting to defraud Fidelity Mutual Insurance. On November 20, Carrie Pitezel admitted involvement in a plan to fake her husband's death and expressed fear that Holmes had killed him. The case thus involved an insurance scheme and a missing husband before it became associated with an enormous supposed death toll. Suspicions expanded as investigators pursued events and people connected with Holmes.
During July 1895, allegations and discoveries accumulated in several locations. On July 27, a lawyer for the Williams family accused Holmes of killing Horace Williams before killing his sisters. Police investigated graves at the Chicago building on July 28 and released the name of Emily Van Tassel as another supposed victim on July 30. On August 2, Patrick Quinlan, who had helped construct the building, and his wife, who had worked for Holmes, turned state's evidence. Philadelphia detective Frank Geyer found two of Pitezel's children in a Toronto cellar in July 1895; investigators later located a third child's remains at an Indianapolis cottage Holmes had rented. The Philadelphia murder trial began on October 28, 1895. At its opening, Holmes refused the court-appointed lawyer and undertook his own defense. Conviction for Benjamin Pitezel's murder followed on November 2, and Holmes was executed on May 7, 1896.
His own accounts complicated the record further. While awaiting execution, Holmes produced an autobiography containing declarations of innocence alongside exaggerations and falsehoods. Sensational newspapers amplified his claims, helping transform his life into a much larger legend. The Chicago building at the center of that legend had shops on its first floor and long-term rentals on its second. The intended third-floor hotel space was never completed, furnished, or opened to the public, according to Selzer. Selzer calls the planned hotel floor a vehicle to swindle suppliers, investors, and insurers. To evade furniture creditors, he hid furnishings in a room whose doorway had been walled up. A janitor eventually revealed the concealment after the furniture company bribed him.
The distinction between the building's reputation and its documented use also changes who the likely victims were. Selzer's confirmed group consisted of people Holmes knew or had befriended, including romantic and business connections, rather than strangers drawn from crowds visiting the World's Fair. His crimes were tied to money-making schemes and the relationships around them. After the execution, another unsupported story claimed that he had escaped and someone else had died in his place. In 2017, an examination of remains exhumed at his descendants' request confirmed his identity through dental records, closing that particular survival rumor.
- HISTORY, Did Serial Killer H.H. Holmes Really Build a Murder Castle? — www.history.com
- The Galveston Daily News, April 15, 1896, page 1 (University of North Texas, Portal to Texas History) — texashistory.unt.edu
- Library of Congress, H.H. Holmes and the Murder Castle: chronology — guides.loc.gov
- Smithsonian Magazine, The Enduring Mystery of H.H. Holmes, Americas First Serial Killer — www.smithsonianmag.com