A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

Richard Nixon and the end of his presidency

Nixon resignation: the letter, the evidence dispute and the transfer of office

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Debunk

Nixon resignation: the letter, the evidence dispute and the transfer of office

The Nixon resignation was a resignation from office on August 9, 1974. The short letter addressed to Secretary of State Henry Kissinger states the act directly: "I hereby resign the Office of President of the United States." The House Judiciary Committee had approved impeachment charges, but the departure itself came through Nixon's signed letter. The proceedings over evidence, the committee's recommendations and the transfer of the presidency were related events with different legal functions.

The dispute over recordings reached the Supreme Court in United States v. Nixon, decided on July 24, 1974. The special prosecutor sought tapes and documents concerning identified presidential conversations for a pending criminal prosecution involving White House staff members and political supporters. Nixon sought to quash the subpoena, asserting executive privilege. The district court had ordered the material submitted for private judicial inspection. The Supreme Court therefore confronted a demand for evidence in a criminal case, rather than a vote on whether the President should remain in office.

The Court rejected an absolute presidential privilege based only on a generalized need for confidential communications. It recognized the importance of presidential confidentiality but held that it could not automatically override the judicial need for relevant evidence in a criminal trial. The opinion carefully limited its scope: it was not resolving the balance applicable to civil litigation, congressional information demands or state secrets. Those boundaries are part of the ruling. It required compliance with judicial process under the circumstances before the Court; it did not itself remove Nixon from office.

The Judiciary Committee's proposed charges proceeded along a separate track. The first charged obstruction of justice following the June 17, 1972, entry into Democratic National Committee headquarters. Its allegations included misleading investigators, withholding evidence, interfering with investigations and facilitating payments intended to secure silence. The text also alleged misuse of the Central Intelligence Agency and misleading public statements about the investigation. These were the committee's stated grounds for impeachment, trial and removal, expressed as accusations requiring further constitutional proceedings.

The second charge addressed abuses of presidential power. It alleged improper use of tax information, discriminatory tax investigations, unlawful surveillance and misuse of executive agencies. The third addressed noncompliance with the committee's own subpoenas, identifying demands issued on April 11, May 15, May 30 and June 24, 1974. The published text records approval votes of 27–11, 28–10 and 21–17 respectively. That third charge makes a particularly concrete distinction: the congressional demand for materials was separate from the prosecutor's subpoena litigated in the Supreme Court.

The Nixon resignation announcement came on the evening of August 8. Speaking from the Oval Office at 9:01 p.m., he told a nationwide radio and television audience that he no longer possessed sufficient political support in Congress. He described earlier hopes of remaining in office through the constitutional process, then said the disappearance of that political base had changed his decision. His explanation centered on the capacity to govern and the time that a continued struggle for personal vindication would consume.

Nixon specified noon on the following day as the effective time he intended for his departure and said Vice President Gerald Ford would take the oath then. He acknowledged that his second term still had roughly two and a half years to run. The Nixon resignation thus interrupted an unfinished term. His address also expressed regret for injuries arising from the events leading to his decision, while describing his judgments as having been made in what he believed were the country's interests. That was his public explanation, distinct from the committee's allegations.

The letter dated August 9 dispensed with the long explanation. It addressed Kissinger as Secretary of State, declared the resignation and ended with Nixon's signature. The American Presidency Project's transcription includes the contemporary delivery note: presidential aide Alexander M. Haig Jr. brought the letter to Kissinger in his White House office at 11:35 a.m. The delivery record and the announced noon departure can be described separately without substituting one for the other. Neither document describes a Senate judgment removing the President.

Ford's own remarks on taking office supply the next event. The official note places the speech at 12:05 p.m. in the White House's East Room, following administration of the oath by Chief Justice Warren E. Burger. Ford acknowledged that he had not been elected President by a national ballot and that he had not campaigned for either the presidency or the vice presidency. He referred instead to the officials who had nominated and confirmed him as Vice President. His authority to assume the presidency followed the vacancy and succession.

Ford promised openness and cooperation, described the constitutional system as working, and asked for prayers for Nixon and his family. The speech referred to Nixon as the former President. The sequence behind the Nixon resignation is therefore unusually tangible: a judicial order concerning evidence, committee recommendations for impeachment, a televised declaration of intent, a delivered resignation letter and an oath taken by the successor. The signed letter performed the departure that the earlier proceedings had placed under mounting pressure.

The Question

How did Richard Nixon leave the presidency during Watergate?

Show the answer

The Answer

Nixon resigned. The House Judiciary Committee had recommended articles of impeachment, but he left office on August 9, 1974, before the proceedings removed him.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.