Amanda Knox: the final acquittal and the evidence behind the dispute
Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito were definitively acquitted in the Meredith Kercher murder case on March 27, 2015, when Italy's highest court overturned their convictions. The result closed the murder proceedings after an earlier acquittal had itself been overturned. It did not settle every separate charge involving Knox. The final decision followed conflicting evaluations of genetic traces on a knife and bra clasp, including disagreement about the statistical value of mixed DNA and the possibility of contamination.
ABC News reported the final decision that day and recorded Amanda Knox speaking outside her mother's home in Seattle. She expressed gratitude for the justice and support she had received, while remembering Kercher as her friend. Sollecito had been attending the proceedings in Rome; Knox remained in the United States. The report stated that no further appeal was possible.
The scientific record had already developed independently of that final decision. In September 2013, Carla Vecchiotti and Silvia Zoppis published their analysis of the Perugia case in Frontiers in Genetics. Vecchiotti had been one of the two experts appointed by the appeal court to review the original genetic examinations. Their assignment concerned the kitchen knife treated as a possible murder weapon and a clasp from Kercher's bra. They were to repeat the analyses if enough material remained, or assess the original laboratory documentation if new testing was impossible.
Their findings were specific. They reported neither blood nor cellular material on the knife blade during their examination, and the available DNA quantity did not permit the repeated amplification they considered necessary. The clasp could not be reexamined because storage in extraction buffer had left it rusty. They also identified additional genetic peaks in the original clasp results that indicated multiple contributors and had not been fully reported. Their conclusions allowed compatibility with Sollecito's profile while leaving contamination during collection or handling unresolved. That combination differs from saying that no genetic information existed at all.
David Balding's 2013 study in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences addressed a separate part of the dispute. He compared interpretations of the clasp's mixed DNA results and developed statistical methods for assessing limited, noisy samples. Some additional peaks weakened the comparison favoring Sollecito, but Balding still found strong support for his being a DNA contributor under the alternatives he examined. His treatment of uncertain peaks also affected the numerical strength of that support. This was a technical evaluation of the genetic mixture, not a conclusion that Sollecito committed the killing.
Balding explicitly left outside his analysis how the DNA arrived on the exhibit. Contamination had been disputed at trial and on appeal, and a statistical comparison of possible contributors could not resolve that history. He also disputed the idea that a single laboratory run must always make evaluation impossible, provided the uncertainty was adequately modeled. The disagreement with the appeal experts therefore had identifiable boundaries. It concerned statistical interpretation and replication, while the integrity of collection and handling remained a separate evidential issue for the courts.
Douglas Linder's Famous Trials dossier identifies the clasp as exhibit 165 and the kitchen knife as exhibit 36. The clasp was photographed on the bedroom floor before its later collection; the knife came from Sollecito's apartment. Police attributed DNA on its handle to Amanda Knox and material on its blade to Kercher. Linder reproduces the Court of Cassation's conclusion that the appealed judgment had seriously misinterpreted the knife evidence and failed to recognize laboratory contamination.
A later primary recording preserves Knox's description of the separate legal proceedings. In a conversation with Phoebe Judge broadcast by Cascade PBS in 2025, she recalled being convicted, acquitted, convicted again and finally acquitted by the Supreme Court. Judge separately raised the court's decision earlier that year to uphold the conviction involving Patrick Lumumba, and Knox acknowledged it. That conviction concerned her accusation against Lumumba during the investigation. The final acquittal of Amanda Knox for Kercher's murder and the conviction concerning Lumumba involved different offenses.
The bathmat footprint was another contested exhibit in the murder prosecution. Linder reproduces images of the bloody print and describes the prosecution's attribution to Sollecito. His summary identifies a measurement problem: the second toe's impression blended with the big toe, affecting the width used for comparison. Linder gives Sollecito's big-toe width as 30 millimeters and the corrected impression as 24.8 millimeters. He also describes defense expert Francesco Vinci's testimony disputing the match. This was a dispute about a particular impression and the measurements assigned to it. It accompanied the separate challenges to the knife and clasp, each with its own collection history and limits.
- ABC News, Amanda Knox “Grateful” Conviction Overturned, March 27, 2015 — contemporaneous verdict report and Knox’s recorded statement — abcnews.com
- Carla Vecchiotti and Silvia Zoppis, DNA and the law in Italy: the experience of “the Perugia case” (2013) — court expert’s original discussion, Frontiers in Genetics — www.frontiersin.org
- David J. Balding, Evaluation of mixed-source, low-template DNA profiles in forensic science (2013) — original statistical reanalysis, PNAS via PubMed Central — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Douglas O. Linder, Key Prosecution Evidence in the Amanda Knox Trial — exhibits and reproduced Court of Cassation knife-evidence passage, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- Cascade PBS Ideas Festival, Criminal: Accused, Acquitted, Ascendant, broadcast June 20, 2025 — official recording and transcript of Amanda Knox with Phoebe Judge — www.pbs.org