Lizzie Borden verdict: testimony, household records, and acquittal
The Lizzie Borden verdict was an acquittal. A Massachusetts jury found her not guilty of murdering her father, Andrew, and her stepmother, Abby, on June 20, 1893. The two had been killed at their home in Fall River on August 4, 1892. Borden's arrest and the decision to bring her to trial were earlier stages of the prosecution. Neither was the final judgment delivered by the jury at New Bedford, where the murder trial opened on June 5, 1893.
Borden's own inquest testimony preserved ordinary household and financial details that became part of the investigation. She gave her name as Lizzie Andrew Borden, explaining that Lizzie was her christened name, and said that she was 32. Abby was her stepmother; her own mother had died when she was a small child. The family had occupied the Second Street house for about 20 years, according to her recollection. Borden said that the building had previously accommodated two households, but that her family had subsequently occupied the whole property.
Under questioning by District Attorney Hosea Knowlton, Borden described some of her father's property without claiming to know his total wealth. She identified farms in Swansea and several holdings in Fall River. She also described a house on Ferry Street that her father had given to her and Emma and later bought back. Her account put the payment at $5,000, divided equally between the sisters. When Knowlton asked about a will, she reported only having heard her uncle mention one. She said her father had never discussed the matter with her. These were her statements at the inquest, before the criminal trial.
Bridget Sullivan supplied a different perspective: that of the family's sole resident domestic servant. In her June 7 trial testimony, she said she had worked for the Bordens for two years and nine months. Born in Ireland, she had lived in Newport and South Bethlehem before coming to Fall River. Lizzie and Emma sometimes called her Maggie. Sullivan's work included laundry, cooking, and sweeping, while the family attended to its own bedrooms. Her room was on the third floor. Her account described a household she knew through years of daily work, rather than through the investigation alone.
Sullivan's testimony also placed her in different parts of the house during the morning of the killings. Abby had assigned her to wash the windows. She described admitting Andrew when he returned home, then continuing her work. Later, she went to her own room and heard the City Hall bell at 11. Lizzie's call brought her downstairs. Sullivan estimated that it came 10 or 15 minutes after the bell, expressly qualifying the timing as her judgment. Such testimony supplied a sequence of observations. Sullivan did not describe witnessing either killing, and her movements left intervals in which she was occupied elsewhere.
Emma's June 16 testimony brought family relationships and financial documents into the courtroom. Her lawyer produced a list of Lizzie's bank deposits and shares, including interests in the Fall River National Bank and Merchants' Manufacturing Company. Emma also described a ring that Andrew wore. Lizzie had given it to him 10 or 15 years earlier, Emma recalled, and he had worn it continually afterward. The ring had previously belonged to Lizzie. That recollection supplied a specific example of affection within the family, offered by a witness who was herself the defendant's sister.
Clothing evidence was more complicated than a single reference to a blue dress. Emma recalled approximately 18 or 19 dresses in a clothes closet at the time of a search. Ten had blue as a significant color: eight belonged to Lizzie and two to Emma. She acknowledged that the inventory she brought to court had been prepared from memory about a week before her testimony. She also described a light blue cotton Bedford cord dress and said it had acquired paint marks shortly after being made. Her testimony therefore included both detailed recollections and the limits of a retrospective inventory.
The Lizzie Borden verdict followed significant rulings on admissible evidence. In Linder's historical reconstruction, the three judges excluded her inquest testimony because they regarded her position during that examination as effectively that of an accused prisoner, without her lawyer present. Her earlier statements therefore did not simply become trial evidence because investigators had obtained them. Linder also describes the defense's reliance on contradictions among prosecution witnesses and Justice Justin Dewey's favorable discussion of her character. The jury returned its decision after about 90 minutes. The Lizzie Borden verdict left her free; she subsequently lived with Emma at Maplecroft in Fall River. She died in 1927 and was buried beside her father and stepmother.
- Douglas O. Linder, The Trial of Lizzie Borden: An Account, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- Lizzie Borden, inquest testimony, August 9–11, 1892, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- Bridget Sullivan, trial testimony, June 7, 1893, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- Emma Borden, trial testimony, June 16, 1893, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- HISTORY.com Editors, Lizzie Borden acquitted of parents’ murders — www.history.com