A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

A colonial court’s order and the punishment it chose

Anne Hutchinson trial: banishment, confinement, and a second proceeding

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Debunk

Anne Hutchinson trial: banishment, confinement, and a second proceeding

The Anne Hutchinson trial in November 1637 ended with an order of banishment from Massachusetts Bay, with confinement until she was sent away. The surviving examination records Governor John Winthrop announcing that sentence after the General Court considered her religious meetings and statements about ministers. His language excluded her from the colony's jurisdiction as a woman considered unfit for its society. It was an order of expulsion and imprisonment pending departure. The court did not sentence her to execution, and her life continued in other settlements after Massachusetts.

The National Park Service places Hutchinson's beginnings in England in 1591. Her father, Francis Marbury, was a Puritan minister who had himself been jailed for criticizing bishops. She married William Hutchinson in 1612. Both were followers of John Cotton, and when Cotton became a minister in Boston, Massachusetts, the family followed him across the Atlantic. Linder places their arrival in September 1634 and her admission to Boston’s church six weeks afterward. The religious connection preceded the conflict with Massachusetts authorities. Hutchinson came to the colony as an admirer of one of its ministers, rather than as an opponent of its entire religious project.

In Boston, Hutchinson hosted meetings at which women discussed sermons and Scripture. Her own interpretations acquired a following and eventually attracted hostility from civic and religious leaders. The Park Service attributes part of the conflict to her insistence that divine communication did not require clerical intervention. Peter J. Gomes, writing in Harvard Magazine, describes the movement from commentary on Cotton's sermons to criticism of the religious establishment. He also notes that the gatherings attracted Henry Vane, whose loss of the governorship to Winthrop in 1637 changed the political setting of the controversy.

Douglas O. Linder dates the opening of the Anne Hutchinson trial to November 7, 1637, in a meetinghouse at Cambridge, also called Newtown. Nine magistrates and 31 deputies made up the General Court. Its authority combined legislative, executive, and judicial functions under the colony's royal charter. Winthrop was both governor and the leading judicial figure confronting Hutchinson. Ministers attended as witnesses. The proceeding placed a religious dissenter before the same governing body that exercised extensive authority over colonial life, with theological disagreement and political obedience treated together.

The examination records Hutchinson repeatedly seeking a precise statement of the law she had broken. Winthrop connected her support for religious dissenters with disobedience to authority and invoked the commandment concerning respect for parents. The magistrates and ministers occupied the position of communal fathers in that argument. Her domestic meetings were another contested subject. Hutchinson defended religious instruction by older women through a passage in Titus. The exchange also distinguished a meeting for women from another gathering involving men and women. The record preserves her challenges to the accusations as well as the governor's assertion of the court's authority over her.

Witness testimony concerned what Hutchinson had said about the colony's ministers. In Linder's account, John Coggeshall disputed the scope of the remarks attributed to her, while Thomas Leverett distinguished criticism of the clarity of their preaching from an accusation that they preached a different doctrine. Cotton likewise did not confirm the accusation in its strongest form. Hutchinson then asserted that she had received an immediate revelation from God. The judges treated that declaration as a further basis for condemnation. Their judgment followed a dispute about her words and claimed authority, rather than a unanimous agreement among witnesses about every allegation.

A second proceeding concerned membership in the Boston church. Gomes distinguishes the civil judgment from the ecclesiastical process that followed during Hutchinson's confinement. In 1638, she faced her former religious community, and Cotton had turned against her. Linder records her excommunication before her departure from Massachusetts. Exclusion from the congregation and exclusion from the colony were related consequences, delivered by different authorities. Hutchinson spent the intervening winter under house arrest in Roxbury, awaiting the removal ordered in the Anne Hutchinson trial.

The Portsmouth Compact supplies a separate record of the movement toward another settlement. Dated March 7, 1638, it incorporated its signatories into a political body under Christian principles. William Coddington, John Clarke, William Hutchinson, and John Coggeshall appear among the names attached to it. Anne's name does not. The National Park Service describes Roger Williams's assistance with obtaining land from the Narragansett and the Hutchinson family's participation in the settlement on Aquidneck Island. After her husband's death in 1642, Anne moved to what became New York. She was killed there in 1643. Massachusetts received a bronze statue commemorating her in 1922, with an inscription honoring civil liberty and religious toleration.

True or False?

Massachusetts Bay’s General Court sentenced Anne Hutchinson to death in 1637.

Show the answer

The Record

False. The court ordered her banished from its jurisdiction and confined until she was sent away, as the surviving examination records.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.