Bounty court-martial: the different judgments within a captured crew
The Bounty court-martial acquitted four of its ten defendants in September 1792. They were Charles Norman, Joseph Coleman, Thomas McIntosh, and Michael Byrn, whose surname also appears as Byrne. The verdict distinguished them from six other men whom the court sentenced to death. John Barrow reproduced the judgment in his 1831 history of the mutiny, dating its delivery to September 18, 1792. The court's decision separated the men who remained aboard the ship in 1789 into different legal categories, despite their arrival together as accused prisoners.
The Bounty court-martial opened on September 12 aboard the Duke in Portsmouth Harbour. Vice-Admiral Lord Hood presided, with naval captains sitting in judgment. Douglas O. Linder's historical account describes a joint proceeding against the ten men, all facing the charge of mutiny. Their former commander, William Bligh, was absent on another voyage. Judge Advocate Moses Greetham opened proceedings with an account of the expedition and a reading of Bligh's report. The conduct of the accused during the mutiny, their relationship to the men who took command, and the reasons they had remained aboard became matters for examination. They were the surviving prisoners returned from Pandora, whose wreck had killed four other Bounty captives.
Bligh's own published account preceded that proceeding. His Narrative appeared in 1790 and described the loss of his ship during the voyage from Tahiti. Although his language condemned the mutineers strongly, it did not place everyone left aboard in the same position. Bligh identified Coleman, the armourer, and McIntosh and Norman, the two carpenter's mates, as having been kept against their wishes. He recalled their appeals for him to remember that they had taken no part in the transaction. For Byrn, he used a different qualification: he had been told that the man likewise wanted to leave.
The difference in wording reflected the limits Bligh himself placed on those particular statements. His account presented the declarations of three men as something addressed to him and the information about Byrn as something reported. It also identified the ship's clerk, John Samuel, as the person who preserved Bligh's journals, commission, and other papers. Bligh attached importance to those documents as evidence of his conduct and character. His Narrative therefore combined accusations against the seizure's participants, statements favorable to several detained men, and an explanation of the records that had accompanied him home.
John Fryer's testimony in the Bounty court-martial added another participant's recollections. The ship's master said Coleman had repeatedly declared that he had no hand in the affair. He described McIntosh and Norman leaning over the rail and apparently crying. Fryer also recalled his exchange with James Morrison, the boatswain's mate. Morrison had denied involvement but told him it was too late. Under cross-examination, Fryer did not recall Morrison's claimed offer to help recover the ship. He nevertheless described Morrison's manner as friendly and accepted that the remark could have been well intended.
Fryer expressly limited other portions of his evidence. He said the confusion aboard and the subsequent demands of the open-boat voyage had prevented contemporaneous notes. His account was given from recollection. When pressed about people carrying arms, he distinguished those he had personally seen from information heard from others in the boat. He also said his attention had been occupied by conversations with Bligh. Such qualifications accompanied testimony from a witness supporting the prosecution, rather than appearing only in statements from the accused.
The judgment of the Bounty court-martial also separated conviction from a recommendation for mercy. In the text reproduced by Barrow, Peter Heywood and Morrison were among the six men condemned, while the court earnestly recommended both to the king's mercy. They were not among the four acquitted defendants. That distinction also appears in Heywood's subsequent history. Royal Museums Greenwich records that he obtained a royal pardon through Lord Chatham's interest and resumed his naval career. The pardon followed his conviction and death sentence; it was a different outcome from the acquittals announced for Norman, Coleman, McIntosh, and Byrn.
Heywood's later service extended well beyond the proceedings. The Greenwich collection account places him aboard Lord Howe's flagship Queen Charlotte in 1794 and records his promotion to acting lieutenant that August, confirmed in March 1795. He later undertook surveying work in the East Indies and South America and became a captain in 1803. In 1818, he declined an offer to become Admiralty Hydrographer and recommended Francis Beaufort. His last sea appointment was command of Montagu in 1813, with service in the North Sea and Mediterranean until July 1816. John Simpson's oil portrait, painted during Heywood's retirement and shown at the Royal Academy in 1822, depicts him in a captain's uniform.
- John Barrow, The Eventful History of the Mutiny and Piratical Seizure of H.M.S. Bounty (1831), Chapter 6: reproduced court verdict, Project Gutenberg — www.gutenberg.org
- Douglas O. Linder, The Court-Martial of the Bounty Mutineers: An Account, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- William Bligh, A Narrative of the Mutiny on Board His Majesty’s Ship Bounty (1790), Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- John Fryer, court-martial testimony, September 12, 1792, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- Royal Museums Greenwich, Captain Peter Heywood, 1772–1831: collection record BHC2766 — www.rmg.co.uk