A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

The Duke lacrosse case decision

Duke lacrosse: the dismissal, the innocence finding and the surviving records

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Debunk

Duke lacrosse: the dismissal, the innocence finding and the surviving records

Duke lacrosse players David Evans, Collin Finnerty and Reade Seligmann were innocent of the charges against them, North Carolina Attorney General Roy Cooper announced on April 11, 2007. Duke's contemporaneous collection preserves his wording: “We believe these three individuals are innocent of these charges.” His decision dismissed the remaining sexual-offense and kidnapping charges; the rape charges had already been dropped. Cooper had taken over in January, after ethics charges against Durham District Attorney Mike Nifong. The new prosecutor explicitly rejected the alleged attack, going beyond the procedural act of ending the prosecution.

The Duke lacrosse evidence dispute is described in the Fourth Circuit's 2012 decision in Evans v. Chalmers. Its chronology describes an initial state laboratory examination and a more sensitive private laboratory examination. According to the civil complaints summarized there, the private laboratory found DNA from several men but excluded the lacrosse players as contributors. The complaints alleged that the May 2006 report supplied to the defense omitted those exclusionary results. They also described an April photo procedure showing only white team members, after earlier viewings had produced no identification of an attacker.

Those details appear in a civil appeal concerning Durham and its officials, including assertions of immunity. The appellate judges expressly summarized the facts alleged in amended complaints, applying rules requiring acceptance of pleaded facts when assessing dismissal motions. The same chronology records a September 22, 2006, order requiring disclosure of the laboratories' complete files and underlying data. In December, private laboratory employees acknowledged concealing results. The disputed report therefore had a continuing procedural history: further disclosure, examination of the underlying material and testimony about what the initial presentation had omitted.

Nifong's response to the dismissal is preserved in a statement reported by ABC News on April 12. He offered an apology to the three students for any mistaken judgments and accepted the decision to drop the charges. His lawyer, David Freedman, separately told ABC that Nifong considered dismissal appropriate following the special prosecutors' analysis. Acceptance of that result did not mean agreement about Nifong's earlier conduct. Freedman defended the time taken to resolve the case and resisted treating the delay itself as evidence of misconduct.

ABC also interviewed Jim Cooney, Seligmann's lawyer, whose criticism concerned the handling of facts. Cooney distinguished an erroneous judgment reached after considering evidence from a judgment made without considering it. Freedman resisted blaming Nifong for the duration of the Duke lacrosse prosecution and said the process had eventually worked for the players. He declined to address Cooper's specific criticisms directly, saying Nifong would have an opportunity to respond during disciplinary hearings. The prosecutor's defense therefore continued even as his lawyer accepted the criminal case's end.

Duke President Richard Brodhead's written statement on April 11 placed particular emphasis on Cooper's affirmative finding. He welcomed the end of the remaining charges and described the year as deeply unfair to the students and their families. He stressed that the attorney general had determined them innocent, rather than relying on a narrow legal ground for dismissal. Brodhead also praised the evidential review and said he expected a similarly thorough State Bar examination of the district attorney's conduct. The statement therefore separated vindication of the players from professional scrutiny of the prosecutor.

Brodhead also defended his own earlier position. He said he had consistently recognized the students' presumption of innocence while looking to the legal system to assess the charges. He committed Duke to learning from the experience and described the effect of unsubstantiated allegations on the players, their teammates and the university. This was the university president's institutional response, including an explanation of his conduct. Its immediate significance lay in welcoming Cooper's conclusion while acknowledging that the university itself still had matters to examine.

A second university statement followed on April 27, when Cooper's office released its Summary of Conclusions. Senior vice president John F. Burness said the document showed an absence of credible evidence supporting any conclusion other than innocence for Evans, Finnerty and Seligmann. He welcomed it as he had welcomed the April 11 announcement, then pointed again to the pending State Bar review. The original statement identifies both the later release of the prosecutor's written conclusions and Duke's response. It is a university endorsement of that review, rather than the full investigative file itself.

The professional proceedings subsequently produced a separate outcome. Duke's historical collection records that a State Bar disciplinary panel found in June 2007 that Nifong had made prejudicial public comments, intentionally withheld DNA evidence and made false statements to court officials. The panel called for disbarment, and he resigned as district attorney. Those findings concerned his conduct in office. The Duke lacrosse criminal charges had already ended with Cooper's dismissal and his explicit description of the three accused men as innocent.

The Question

What word did North Carolina's attorney general use to describe the three accused Duke lacrosse players when dismissing the charges?

Show the answer

The Answer

Innocent. Roy Cooper dismissed all charges against the three players in April 2007 after his office took over the case.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.