A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

Bonnie Parker and the famous photograph

Bonnie Parker: the borrowed cigar and the surviving photographs

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Debunk

Bonnie Parker: the borrowed cigar and the surviving photographs

Bonnie Parker smoked cigarettes. The cigar between her teeth in the famous 1933 photograph was borrowed for the pose, according to her traveling companion W. D. Jones. That recollection and the photograph preserve different kinds of evidence. The photograph fixes a moment with a cigar and a gun; Jones described what happened around the camera. The difference matters because a single playful exposure became a lasting description of Parker's everyday behavior.

The photograph came to public attention after the confrontation at Joplin, Missouri, on April 13, 1933. Police approached the apartment occupied by Parker, Clyde Barrow, Jones, Buck Barrow and Blanche Barrow expecting to investigate bootleggers. Gunfire followed, two officers died, and the five occupants escaped. A camera and undeveloped film remained behind. The photographs therefore reached the newspapers through a police discovery, rather than through a publicity session arranged with the fugitives.

PBS's 2017 documentary Bonnie & Clyde dates the Joplin Globe's publication to April 15. It describes the pictures spreading into newspapers and magazines across the country.

Jeff Guinn's 2009 Smithsonian treatment reproduces the cigar photograph and quotes Jones's later recollection that Bonnie Parker smoked cigarettes and that he supplied the cigar. Guinn also describes other poses made by the companions, including pictures that resembled their earlier amusement-park photographs with toy guns. The cigar image belongs to that setting of performance. Jones's recollection supplies the cigarette habit; the visible cigar alone does not establish how often Parker smoked one, or whether she regularly did so at all.

A separate photograph preserved in the FBI's image repository shows Bonnie Parker leaning against the back of a car with two guns in her belt. The bureau's caption describes the weapons and posture. Its historical case page also presents a photograph of Parker and Barrow playfully posing outdoors with guns. These are records of the pair displaying themselves to a camera. Neither caption identifies a particular robbery being committed at the instant of exposure. The weapons are visible objects, while an action attributed to their holder requires its own evidence.

The surviving identification material had a more specific practical purpose. The FBI preserves Identification Order No. 1227 for Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow, dated May 21, 1934. Its case history describes the distribution of wanted notices containing photographs, fingerprints, physical descriptions and criminal records. Those features served the search for particular people. A recognizable face could help an officer identify a fugitive even when a popular description attached to that face was unreliable. The usefulness of a photograph for identification did not make every newspaper characterization accurate.

The federal case developed through evidence quite different from the cigar pose. According to the FBI's history, investigators traced a prescription bottle in a stolen Illinois automobile to a drugstore in Nacogdoches, Texas. The medicine had been prescribed to Clyde Barrow's aunt. Investigators connected the bottle, visits to the aunt and the vehicle used by Barrow, Parker and L. C. Barrow. The bureau reported that L. C. had obtained the empty bottle from a son of the woman for whom the prescription was originally filled. On May 20, 1933, a United States commissioner in Dallas issued a warrant charging Parker and Barrow with transporting that stolen automobile from Dallas into Oklahoma. The interstate movement supplied the federal charge.

That sequence puts a legal boundary around the visual publicity. The FBI says its jurisdiction concerned transportation of a stolen automobile, while local and state authorities pursued other offenses. The bureau circulated identifying material across jurisdictions, and agents followed leads through several states. The photograph of a woman with a gun was not itself the federal charging instrument. The warrant concerned an identified vehicle and its movement across a state line, facts that could be investigated independently of the dramatic poses.

The contemporary newsreel excerpts preserved in American Experience show how far the spectacle extended. An announcer describes the crowd filing past Barrow's body in a Dallas funeral home; another passage says the crowd at Parker's funeral home was still larger. These are contemporary descriptions of public attention, preserved inside a later film. They document the scale of the attraction without establishing the cigarette habit. The same documentary separates those archival announcements from modern interviews with relatives and historians, whose explanations were recorded long afterward.

The FBI dates the deaths of Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow to May 23, 1934, two days after the identification order. Their photographs survived both the pursuit and the people pictured. The cigar exposure, the armed poses, the federal warrant and the funeral newsreels each retain a different event: performance, identification, accusation and public spectacle. For Parker's habitual smoking, the specific testimony remains Jones's recollection of cigarettes and a borrowed cigar.

The Question

What did Bonnie Parker habitually smoke?

Show the answer

The Answer

Cigarettes. The famous cigar pose came from photographs police recovered at the gang's Joplin hideout, helping create a public image that differed from her smoking habit.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.