A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

Does surviving abuse make someone an abuser later in life?

Childhood victimization: Clinical files, follow-up records, and uncertain pathways

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Debunk

Childhood victimization: Clinical files, follow-up records, and uncertain pathways

Childhood victimization does not make sexual offending inevitable. The Justice Department's research synthesis explicitly rejects an automatic progression from being sexually abused to abusing others. It also reports that, although offenders disclose higher rates of childhood sexual abuse than the general population, most perpetrators were not sexually abused as children. Those findings concern two different groups: survivors followed into later life, and perpetrators whose earlier experiences are investigated. Research on the connection depends on which group was selected, what behavior was measured, and how the evidence was collected.

A 2001 investigation by M. Glasser and colleagues examined clinical files for 843 people attending a specialist forensic psychotherapy center. Among 747 men, 35 percent of perpetrators had a reported history of victimization, compared with 11 percent of non-perpetrators. The researchers found an association within that clinical population. The women's results were different: 43 percent of the 96 women had been victims, but only one woman was a perpetrator. The authors described evidence for a victim-to-victimizer pattern in a minority subgroup of male perpetrators, rather than in all survivors.

The same investigation identified limits to its own findings about childhood victimization. Its participants came from an unusual, selected treatment population and did not represent the wider population of victims or perpetrators. The case files were retrospective, and the information had not been collected systematically for research. Recall bias and a lack of systematic checks on denial of abusive behavior were additional concerns. The recorded association was therefore a result from particular clinical files. It could not supply a general population forecast for every child who had experienced sexual abuse.

Cathy Spatz Widom and Christina Massey used a different design in their 2015 study. They began with substantiated childhood abuse and neglect cases, rather than selecting adults because they had sexually offended. The original cases came from a Midwestern metropolitan county during 1967–1971. The researchers matched 908 affected children with 667 comparison children by age, sex, race or ethnicity, and approximate family social class. Follow-up continued through 2013, when the mean age was 51. Federal and state criminal records and state sex-offender registries supplied the later outcome information.

The results varied by type of childhood victimization. Physical abuse and neglect were each associated with significantly increased odds of arrest for a sex offense. For childhood sexual abuse, the adjusted odds ratio was 2.13, with a 95 percent confidence interval of 0.83–5.47; the result did not reach statistical significance. The researchers also found no support for specialization in sex crimes. Their conclusion concerned the proposed unique risk attached to sexual abuse, not a claim that childhood maltreatment has no consequences or that every survivor has identical risks and experiences.

The definition of the outcome had already mattered in Widom's 1995 NIJ research brief. That investigation found higher arrest risks among people sexually victimized in childhood compared with people without documented abuse or neglect. However, the risk was no higher than for victims of other maltreatment. Sexual abuse was specifically associated with increased arrest risk for prostitution compared with other abuse groups. For rape and sodomy arrests, people physically abused in childhood tended to have greater risk than either sexual-abuse survivors or comparison participants. A broad category of sex-crime arrests therefore contained quite different outcomes.

That earlier investigation also examined a proposed progression from sexual abuse to running away and then to prostitution. The expected pathway was not supported. Its findings concerned recorded arrests, rather than a complete inventory of all conduct. The later 2015 investigation likewise used criminal-history records. The clinical study, by contrast, drew on treatment files. These differences in measurement help explain why a finding about one defined outcome cannot simply be transferred to another, or turned into a prediction about an individual survivor's future behavior.

Susan Bailey's commentary accompanying the 2001 clinical study explicitly favored developmental pathways over inevitability. She discussed combinations of motivating and mediating factors and warned that the findings concerned a possible minority subgroup within a much wider picture. Her commentary also challenged the treatment of younger participants as adults with fixed personalities and called for long-term evaluation of interventions. Those were clinical interpretations and proposals for further work, distinct from the original file review's measured associations. They pointed toward individual assessment and changing circumstances rather than a fixed identity assigned by childhood experience.

The Justice Department's synthesis similarly describes multiple contributing factors and cautions about dependence on offenders' self-reports. Childhood victimization can be relevant to research on later offending without becoming a sentence imposed on survivors. Associations within treatment samples, differences between maltreatment groups, and outcomes recorded over decades all require their own qualifications. None establishes an automatic transfer from suffering sexual abuse to committing it.

True or False?

Sexually abused children grow up to become sexual abusers — that's just how the cycle works.

Show the answer

The Record

The cycle mostly doesn't. Early childhood victimization does not automatically lead to sexually aggressive behavior. Sex offenders report higher rates of childhood sexual abuse than the general population, but the majority of perpetrators were not abused as children (Berliner & Elliott, 2002; Putnam, 2003). The "cycle of abuse" does not describe an automatic path from victimization to perpetration. Believing in an automatic cycle and documenting one are different things; victimization does not make survivors future criminals.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.