A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

Dukakis and the Sacco-Vanzetti case

The Dukakis proclamation: the official act and the earlier demands for justice

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Debunk

The Dukakis proclamation: the official act and the earlier demands for justice

The Dukakis proclamation designated August 23, 1977, as Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti Memorial Day and called for the stigma attached to their names to be removed. It did not pardon the men or declare them innocent. Its subject was the fairness of a prosecution that had ended with their executions in 1927. That distinction runs through the surviving materials: a governor's later explanation, contemporary defense publications, a prison letter and the legal review commissioned for the anniversary.

Michael Dukakis described his choice directly in a 2014 interview published by GBH. He said that he could not legally issue a posthumous pardon, but believed a proclamation acknowledging grave injustice was worthwhile. Those are his retrospective statements about his own decision. He also connected the case to his longstanding opposition to capital punishment: once people have been executed, a later recognition of error cannot bring them back. The interview supplies a participant's explanation of the action, rather than a new judicial ruling about who committed the murders.

The legal counsel's review had a narrower assignment than retrying the case. As summarized in Wikipedia's documented section on the Dukakis proclamation, the governor requested an assessment of whether the convictions and executions were unfair under contemporary legal standards. The review identified concerns about prejudicial cross-examination, the trial judge's hostility, incomplete evidence and later eyewitness material. It also examined jury instructions that emphasized conduct at arrest and physical evidence subsequently disputed. Its criticism of the old appellate system concerned safeguards unavailable at the time, not an assertion that the absence of a reversal settled the fairness issue.

Louis Bernheimer's pamphlet, The Trial of Sacco and Vanzetti, was dated May 15, 1927, shortly after the death sentences. It drew on Felix Frankfurter's examination of the written trial record and advocated against the convictions. Bernheimer divided the prosecution's evidence into eyewitness identification, conduct interpreted as consciousness of guilt, and ballistics. His summary placed the trial at Dedham, beginning on May 31, 1921. By the time he published, the verdict had stood for years, but opponents were still challenging the testimony on which it rested.

Bernheimer emphasized changes in eyewitness certainty. Frances Devlin had initially declined to identify Sacco positively, then expressed certainty at trial. He reproduced her explanation that the magnitude of the crime had originally made her hesitate. Mary Splaine, he wrote, supplied sixteen details of Sacco's appearance after seeing the moving car briefly from about sixty feet away. Two witnesses on the factory floor above Splaine and Devlin had substantially the same view but could identify nobody. These were contemporary defense objections to identification evidence, presented in an advocacy publication rather than findings from a later retrial.

John Dos Passos's Facing the Chair, published by the Sacco-Vanzetti Defense Committee in 1927, reproduces another dispute. Captain William H. Proctor's trial testimony described the fatal bullet as compatible with having been fired from Sacco's pistol. In an affidavit dated October 22, 1923, Proctor said he meant compatibility with a Colt automatic of that type, and had not identified that particular pistol as the source. He said he had told the prosecution of that limitation before trial. His affidavit challenged the apparent strength of the connection between the bullet and the defendant's weapon.

The same publication includes affidavits responding to Proctor. Former district attorney Frederick Katzmann said Proctor had described a Colt automatic, rather than Sacco's particular weapon. Harold Williams disputed Proctor's description of repeated discussions before trial. Dos Passos also described Judge Webster Thayer's charge as treating Proctor's evidence as an identification of Sacco's pistol. These conflicting statements concerned both the scope of the expert's opinion and the way that opinion reached the jury. They were submitted during efforts to obtain a new trial, long before the Dukakis proclamation revisited fairness in the proceedings.

Mass Humanities reproduces Vanzetti's August 21, 1927, letter to Sacco's son Dante, written two days before the executions. Vanzetti asserted both men's innocence and praised Sacco's commitment to liberty and justice. He urged Dante to become brave, honor his father and continue the struggle against oppression. He also complained that they had been denied a new trial. The letter joined a personal appeal to a child with the political convictions Vanzetti believed had brought the men to the death house. Protecting the family's name was already an explicit concern in that final message.

The Dukakis proclamation addressed that stigma half a century later. As quoted by Mass Humanities, it condemned prejudice against foreigners and hostility toward unconventional political views in the proceedings, while calling for disgrace to be removed from the men's names. The organization distinguishes this recognition from a determination of guilt or innocence. GBH's 2014 report also recalled the action's political controversy, including a senator's threat of impeachment. He remained satisfied that issuing it had been worthwhile. His official response to the executions was a memorial observance and acknowledgment of injustice.

The Question

What formal action did Massachusetts Governor Michael Dukakis take in 1977 concerning the two men executed half a century earlier?

Show the answer

The Answer

He issued a proclamation, without a pardon or a declaration of innocence. It said Sacco and Vanzetti had been unfairly tried and convicted and that disgrace should be removed from their names.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.