A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

The sentencing of Leopold and Loeb

Leopold and Loeb: The sentence and the lives that followed

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · True Crime Debunk

Leopold and Loeb: The sentence and the lives that followed

Leopold and Loeb received life imprisonment for murder and an additional 99 years for kidnapping. Judge John R. Caverly imposed those sentences on September 10, 1924, after a defense led by Clarence Darrow. The victim was Bobby Franks, a Chicago schoolboy who had played tennis at the Loeb residence. His killers were University of Chicago students, ages 19 and 18, who hoped to demonstrate their intellectual superiority through a crime committed without consequences.

The planning lasted seven months and included both the abduction and the disposal of the body. A ransom demand was intended to conceal the nature of the crime and its motive, with payment instructions delivered in a complicated sequence. On May 21, 1924, the pair offered Franks a ride as he walked home from school. He initially declined because he was close to his destination, but Loeb persuaded him to enter by mentioning a tennis racket. After the killing, they concealed his body in a culvert near Wolf Lake. Its discovery the next day ended their attempted ransom collection.

The investigation connected Leopold and Loeb to the killing through details that their elaborate preparation had left exposed. Police found eyeglasses near the body with an unusual hinge purchased by only three customers in Chicago; Leopold was among them. He suggested they could have fallen from his pocket during a bird-watching trip. The pair also said they had driven Leopold's car on the night of the murder, but his chauffeur said he had spent the evening repairing it. Both men eventually confessed, although each identified the other as the person who had killed Franks.

For Leopold and Loeb, the defense strategy shifted the courtroom's attention to punishment. Their families retained Darrow, a committed opponent of capital punishment, as lead counsel. Although a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity had been widely anticipated, he concluded that a jury trial would almost certainly lead to conviction and a death sentence. He chose guilty pleas instead, hoping to persuade Caverly to impose life imprisonment. With the pleas already accepted, the proceedings were an extended sentencing hearing.

The hearing ran for just over a month, and prosecutor Robert E. Crowe presented witnesses detailing the crime. The defense brought extensive psychiatric testimony to establish mitigating circumstances. Darrow's concluding plea lasted about twelve hours and emphasized the defendants' youth and immaturity while criticizing the justice system's methods and punishments as inhumane. He argued that upbringing and environment shaped the young men and appealed for mercy. His plea also asked the judge to consider their families, describing the collapse of their parents' hopes. Looking beyond the defendants, he urged the court to consider the future of other children who might face judgment.

Prison life brought Leopold and Loeb into factory work before they developed a shared educational project. At Joliet Prison, Leopold worked in the chair factory's rattan section and Loeb in the same factory's cabinet-making department. Leopold moved to Stateville Penitentiary in May 1925 and later helped organize the prison library; he also suffered appendicitis during his imprisonment. Loeb transferred to Stateville in late 1930, after remaining at Joliet during the earlier part of his sentence. Once together there, they obtained permission from the warden in late 1932 to create a correspondence school for prisoners, making education part of their prison lives. Their relationship continued despite earlier efforts to keep them apart.

Loeb died following an attack by another inmate in 1936. Leopold remained in prison for more than two decades after Loeb's death. Their sentences had been imposed together, but their later lives followed different courses. Caverly had chosen imprisonment chiefly because of the defendants' ages, 18 and 19. He also regarded that decision as consistent with Illinois precedents. His decision acknowledged that the offenses allowed a choice of punishments and that the guilty pleas placed responsibility for sentencing on the court. The choice of imprisonment therefore reflected the judge's exercise of the discretion provided by the statutes.

Of Leopold and Loeb, only Leopold lived to leave prison on parole. His autobiography, Life Plus 99 Years, appeared in 1958 during his campaign for release. Paroled on March 13 that year after 33 years in prison, he went to Puerto Rico, where the Brethren Service Commission accepted him as a medical technician. He worked as a laboratory and X-ray assistant, earned a master's degree at the University of Puerto Rico, and studied leprosy. He also pursued bird observation, publishing A Checklist of the Birds of Puerto Rico through the University of Puerto Rico in 1963. He died on August 29, 1971.

The guilty pleas were entered without a prior agreement with the prosecution. Caverly explained that they did not result from a negotiated recommendation about punishment. The state already possessed confessions and supporting evidence. Testimony covered both aggravating and mitigating circumstances, with the parties agreeing that testimony in the murder case could also apply to the kidnapping case. Caverly distinguished the defendants' legal responsibility from broader arguments about the causes of human conduct. He concluded that the legal requirements for an insanity defense had not been met. Those conclusions accompanied his separate decision about the punishment to impose.

The Question

What punishment did the court impose on Leopold and Loeb for killing Bobby Franks?

Show the answer

The Answer

They received life imprisonment for murder plus 99 years for kidnapping. Clarence Darrow argued against capital punishment, and the judge chiefly considered their youth when choosing imprisonment.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.