A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Debunk

Can a checklist of tells really expose a liar?

Behavioral screening: findings from experiments and federal hearings

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Debunk

Behavioral screening: findings from experiments and federal hearings

Behavioral screening needs evidence that a sign predicts the condition being sought. Looking uneasy, shifting position or avoiding eye contact is not by itself a validated general test for lying. The distinction between appearing deceptive and actually making a false statement is measurable, and experiments have found that the two can diverge. Federal scrutiny of airport behavior detection exposed a related difficulty: confidence in observing conduct did not establish that the selected indicators could reliably identify a threat to aviation.

The congressional record preserves the scale of that concern. At a May 25, 2016, House Homeland Security Committee hearing, ranking member Bennie Thompson argued that nearly 2,500 behavior detection officers could be reassigned to checkpoint screening. He cited close to $1 billion spent on the Screening of Passengers by Observation Techniques programme and GAO's repeated concerns about scientific validation. These were Thompson's statements in an oversight hearing, including his proposed staffing remedy. They document a public dispute over resources and evidence, rather than an experimental test of every behavior on a checklist.

TSA administrator Peter Neffenger described operational changes at the same hearing. Federal security directors had received flexibility to redeploy behavior detection officers, and officers had moved into screening checkpoints. A letter entered in the hearing record also summarized GAO's finding that the programme had been deployed nationally without prior validation for identifying suspicious airport passengers. The practical consequence of the evidential gap was therefore visible in staffing decisions. Behavioral screening was being evaluated alongside the need to perform conventional screening functions with the personnel already available.

The November 8, 2017, hearing record gives a more specific assessment. Material submitted to TSA administrator David Pekoske cited GAO's finding that valid evidence was lacking for 28 of 36 revised behavioral indicators used to identify potential aviation threats. TSA's written response described eliminating the standalone behavior detection officer position in January 2017 and integrating the functions into other officers' work. It also described reducing an original list of 90 indicators to 39 for a planned rollout in 2018. Those totals concern different revisions and should not be treated as one unchanged checklist.

TSA defended behavior detection as part of layered security while acknowledging a lack of empirical research on indicators of harmful intent in an aviation setting. Its response described turning to other material, including incident histories, expert interviews and research reviews. The distinction is consequential: an indicator's resemblance to behavior described after an attack is different from prospective evidence that it accurately sorts passengers. These exchanges document the agency's rationale and the validation objection together. They do not turn lying, suspicious appearance and intent to cause harm into interchangeable categories.

A 2018 experiment by Jia Loy, Hannah Rohde and Martin Corley separated actual deception from an observer's judgment in a two-person treasure game. Speakers knew which of two images concealed treasure and tried to mislead listeners, who selected an image. Pauses were associated with more truthful statements, but listeners treated them as evidence of deception. Some self-directed hand and body movements were associated with false statements, while listeners' judgments were more affected by emotional displays. The findings therefore resist an absolute claim that behavior never correlates with lying; the mismatch concerned which signals people used and what those signals actually predicted in that setting.

The game's design also constrained its interpretation. Participants mainly looked at screens, so the researchers coded instances of eye contact rather than treating looking away as an exceptional event. Their statistical analysis compared different possible predictors of speaker truthfulness and listener choices. An observed association within that task does not supply an airport screening threshold or a universal rule about a person's gaze. Behavioral screening requires validation in the conditions where decisions will be made, including the particular outcome being sought.

Josiah King and colleagues examined perceived dishonesty more directly in a 2020 experiment. Participants saw a recorded speaker identify a treasure location while choosing between two pictured objects. Nervous-looking gestures influenced their choices and the direction of their eyes and mouse movements. In the second experiment, the researchers analyzed data from 20 participants and deliberately compared gestures with relaxed, motionless video. This design demonstrated how visible behavior can rapidly shape suspicion. It did not establish that the movements themselves distinguished genuine liars from truthful people in an unscripted investigation.

A separate 2012 study led by Richard Wiseman tested a specific claim about eye direction associated with neuro-linguistic programming. Across three studies, coded eye movements did not match the proposed pattern; teaching the rule did not improve detection, and high-profile press-conference footage supplied no supporting difference. That is evidence against the particular eye-direction rule tested, not a separate experimental verdict on yawning, whistling or every form of blinking. Behavioral screening gains no general license from the existence of an easily observed movement. The primary experiments and hearing records instead require a defined target, a tested relationship and explicit limits on where a result applies.

True or False?

A behavioral screening checklist can spot a liar from averted gaze, rapid blinking, fidgeting, whistling, or yawning.

Show the answer

The Record

False. Those behaviors do not provide a validated, general checklist for identifying liars. Experiments distinguish cues that make a person look deceptive from cues that predict deception, and federal reviews found major gaps in the evidence for TSA behavior indicators.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to True Crime Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.